Отзывы Whiskybase
учтено 30 заметок · текстовых 22 · полнота WB не подтверждена (legacy wb_reviews: один автор — одна запись)
Суммаризация отзывов
Молодой Old Pulteney с доводкой в бочках из-под Пино де Шарант — сладкий, десертный профиль с вином, мёдом, абрикосами и пряной дубовой остротой. Оценки сошлись около 84–85, но фирменная солёно-морская нота потеряна, а молодость солода делит мнения.
развернуть подробно
В аромате доминируют сладость и винные ноты: жёлтые и оранжевые фрукты, засахаренные абрикосы, персики в сиропе, мёд, ваниль, карамель и тоффи, у части дегустаторов — коньячные и ореховые оттенки, порой цветочность и восковистость. Вкус насыщенный, маслянистый и десертный — карамель, тоффи, шоколад, мёд, — но с заметно нарастающей пряностью: перец, чили, корица, табак и интенсивный дуб. Послевкусие среднее или чуть длиннее, перечно-пряное, со сладкими винными нотами, у некоторых уходит в горьковатый дуб. Главная общая претензия — исчезновение определяющего для Old Pulteney солёно-морского характера: доводка слишком перекрыла дистиллятную основу, и многие ощущают молодость солода.
Опытные ревьюеры разошлись сильнее прочих: один резко раскритиковал напиток как незрелый и обречённый эксперимент, где вино не компенсирует навязчивую молодость; другой поставил низкий балл из-за доминирующего для 46% спирта и резкости. Остальные авторитетные авторы оценили его положительно (84–85), признавая, что это уже не привычный Pulteney, но добротный и по-своему оригинальный виски, особенно за свою цену. Менее опытные держатся в том же диапазоне 80–86 и в целом благосклоннее: хвалят купажную сладость, бархатистость и необычность профиля Пино, тогда как критика сводится к горьковатому дубу, лёгкой несобранности сочетания и ощущению искусственности. Разброс оценок узкий и согласованный, расхождение — не в баллах, а в том, считать ли потерю морского характера удачным экспериментом или провалом.
собрано 22/30 текстовых отзывов · полнота WB не подтверждена (собрано локально)
· 2026-07-21 17:53:19 · источник wb_whiskies (историческое поле, без evidence)
Golden color. Light oiliness.
нос · вкус · финиш
| Нос | 84 | Sweet. Malt first, then vanilla. Wine notes. Lots of sweet yellow and orange fruits. Candied apricots. Peaches in syrup. Toffee. Caramel. Vanilla pudding. Maybe a pinch of salt, but generally much more sweet vibes. Feel the wine and dessert underneath. Cognac flavors. |
| Вкус | 85 | Sweet, pleasant. Intense and rich. Caramel, toffee. Dessert. guilt. Pleasant, dessert oak. Dessert chocolate. It can be compared to a nice cognac. Light oiliness. A pinch of spices. Cinnamon. |
| Финиш | 84 | Dessert chocolate. Sweet. Cocoa. Spices. Cinnamon. Minimal spiciness. White pepper. Some salt underneath. Toffee. Salty caramel. Honey. More salt on the second sip. Slightly warming. Medium to medium-long finish. |
Is it the Pulteney I know and love? No. Is it a good whisky? Absolutely.
I'm surprised. Positive. The nose is adorable. 85 points.
I like it quite a bit, but the finish is a bit too bitter for my taste.
нос 87 · вкус 86 · финиш 84
нос 85 · вкус 85 · финиш 83
Malty, a bit fake. The nose is good, but the taste is not quite right. It also has something perfumed and should probably be longer in it. Lt. Destilleriw about 12 years, but I think there are also deitlixh younger ones in there
нос 87 · вкус 85 · финиш 82
https://whiskylovingpianist.wordpress.com/2022/11/10/the-whisky-show-2022-old-rare-part-1/ Apparently, spirit was left maturing in a number of these Charentes casks for far longer than originally planned – around 5 years. Fortunately, they at Pulteney were pleasantly surprised by the results. C: More basic with water, but overall, this works very well – solid Old Pulteney with a twist.
нос 86 · вкус 87 · финиш 86
нос 84 · вкус 85 · финиш 85
нос 84 · вкус 86 · финиш 84
A very nice, spicy bottling that shows its (probable) youth. If you can get it cheaply for around €50, you can buy it without hesitation.
нос · вкус · финиш
| Нос | 84 | Fruity, spicy, still somewhat youthful. Vanilla, oranges, soft apples, pepper, some caramel, anise, cloves, dried blueberries, red fruit gums, mineral notes, roasted hazelnuts, oak spice. |
| Вкус | 85 | Very nice sparkling and spicy start. Lightly creamy and slightly tart in the mouth. Oak spice, vanilla, red grape juice, roasted peanuts and beechnuts, caramel, red fruit compote, Mon Chéri pralines, grapefruit, dates, rose water. |
| Финиш | 83 | Medium-long, tart finish. Oak, grapefruit, roasted hazelnuts, cardboard, anise, cloves. |
Even young whiskies can be delicious if they're aged in good casks. Unfortunately, this one isn't. (Even though Old Pulteney is actually one of my favorite distilleries.)
нос · вкус · финиш
| Нос | 79 | Relatively closed. Then mostly cherries/cherry cake. |
| Вкус | 76 | The oak is decidedly too bitter/woody, and then cherry compote comes in. Pre-aging the barrels with a sweet alcoholic beverage doesn't manage to balance out the less pleasant oak spice. |
| Финиш | 77 | |
Old Pulteney Pineau des Charentes, 46%. 30ml sample consumed July 2024. Aroma - pink mice sweets becoming more raspberry cheesecake. Body - lightly oily. Taste – wine cask is mercifully integrated here. Quite nicely done. Some tangy berry fruit but the biscuity wood compensates. Prickle of salt in finish. Okay stuff. 3.4/81
Sweet wine, toasted oak, vanilla, dried fruits.
Old Pulteney Pineau des Charentes, 46% alc. Original bottling (2022, Coastal Series). Aging: Bourbon casks, finished in Pineau des Charentes wine casks Nose: Juicy orange wedges in diluted honey, along with apricot jam and peach liqueur. This creamy sweetness lingers quite a long time in the glass, the Pulteney needs a lot of time to open up further. There is then some tree resin and a light wood spice, I can also smell a delicate herbal note. Palate: The honey has a stronger effect, peanuts are added, then roasted almonds and the fruit aromas on the nose. The spices seem much stronger, some nutmeg and pepper, there is also a hint of cinnamon. The oak wood has an intense effect and contributes to bitter fir trees. Finish: Medium length, creamy sweetness meets bitter caramel, latte and strong spices. Conclusion: A delicious whisky, certainly, creamy sweet anyway. But the "Maritime Malt" is no longer recognizable, the post-maturation has settled too much on the whisky. Well-crafted daily dram. 83/100 points (2022).
нос · вкус · финиш
| Нос | 85 | It has a slight alcoholic feel. |
| Вкус | 88 | Sweet, with a hint of salty sherry flavor |
| Финиш | 86 | |
Beautiful packaging Dark Gold If you get it on offer, it is highly recommended
нос · вкус · финиш
| Нос | 85 | Sour dough Light grapes Alcohol super integrated grapefruit adhesive Honey walnut |
| Вкус | 86 | barrel type directly recognizable A bit dry Helle Traube Vanilla Honey oak Nutty grapefruit |
| Финиш | 85 | For a while now oak Nutty Something Bitter |
Oxygen is definitely good for him, both in the glass and in the bottle. The wine notes are noticeable but subtle in the background. It is reminiscent of the old 12 with 43% and yet is completely different. The distillery character only comes through to a limited extent. You don't really know whether the combination fits or not. It's not wrong or wrong, but somehow it's not entirely coherent either. In the end, the wine comes through strongest in the finish, with slightly sour notes.
Vertical tasting of WB116461 - Old Pulteney 18-year-old - 86 WB128124 - Old Pulteney 16-year-old - 84 WB218030 - Old Pulteney Pineau des Charentes - 82 S 6.5 Very much a dessert dram. Cask forward. Nothing wrong but coastal jammy whisky is not exactly my cup of tea. It's lacking the delicacy Old Pulteney usually offers.
[January 2022] What a strange combo! I guess most people do not even know what "Pineau des Charentes" wine taste all about, let alone a whisky finished in such strange casks... ..which is truly strange, indeed. The malt is clearly too young ("paedophil"), and the wine cannot compensate for this. Another experiment which was bound to fail (except for the controllers who want to generate as much money as possible in as short time as possible). Try a dram first, before buying a bottle...
нос · вкус · финиш
| Нос | 84 | The colour is deep copper, and the nose offers an immature malt and unusual wine profile, hence something rather strange. To be honest, this is not to my liking as the immature whisky aromas completely dominate. |
| Вкус | 83 | The taste is still somewhat immature, to be honest - which mainly comes from the malt side. The wine is okay but cannot compensate for the rather annoying young malt's flavours. Not my cup of whisky, sorry folks. |
| Финиш | 82 | The dram arrives punchy and peppery on my palate, in a blind setting I would have guessed a cask strength edition way above the actual 46% abv. The finish is of medium length and and stays on the sweet (winey) side of the dram, without adding new impressions. |
Nose: At first sniff, the nose is enveloped by a gentle hint of oats, mixed with a subtle note of glue. But suddenly a fruity explosion spreads out, like a sun-drenched vineyard in late summer. Grapes dance in the scent, accompanied by a hint of wine and the tempting sweetness of fruit gums. But beneath this cheerful fruitiness lies a light, mysterious mustiness that makes you curious, while a hint of gum plays around the senses. Taste: The first sip is like a visit to a vineyard, with pepper notes that tickle the palate. But suddenly a wave of smoke breaks through, wild and biting like a raging thunderstorm. With each subsequent sip, a gentler side of this whisky is revealed, especially with a little water. The sweet smoke becomes milder, almost like the smell of a campfire on the beach. Pepper and salt dance on the tongue, while an extremely oily texture caresses the mouth
нос 86 · вкус 84 · финиш 83
EYE/NOSE Strong golden hue that spontaneously reminds me of mead. Also in the nose I immediately have the scent of a spicy, well-matured mead, certainly also influenced by the eye. Then green pepper, orange tea, apricot jam and a kind of woody-balsamic notes. Are there walnuts too? In any case, also nutty flavors. Floral notes and wax join later. I write down rose petals. And the waxy? Beekeepers sometimes sell self-rolled beeswax candles at Christmas markets, that's about it. PALATE Pleasant velvety mouthfeel. At the beginning a slightly ethereal, almost cooling character, which then, as soon as the alcohol sets in with its 46% ABV, has a warming but never pungent effect. good balance Here, too, I find the spicy, not overly sweet honey wine from the nose. Very occasionally, barrel-aged mead can also be found at medieval markets, which sometimes transports pleasant aromas of wood in addition to the honey sweetness. This is where our Pineau put me. It remains fruity and also a bit mineral, but unlike other Old Pulteneys I've tasted in the recent past. Amarettini and dark chocolate follow on the palate. Not extremely cocoa or dry, but creamy and tasty. FINISH/CONCLUSION The aftertaste is actually not quite as long as I had imagined based on the intense taste. Of course, the ubiquitous vinous honey notes remain. Towards the end it becomes almond and again a bit chocolatey. No real misses. Not bitter, woody or even sulphurous. When I first tasted it, I thought it had sulphur, but this seems to be more of a spicy oak influence, as the notes do not weigh down the tongue uncomfortably and the supposed sulfur does not float to the surface even when water is added. Overall a very round, sweet Old Pulteney. Do I miss the salty-maritime, i.e. the defining basic character of the Old Pulteneys, which I appreciate so much, especially on the 12yo? Well, it would probably have been the icing on the cake. However, the malt has its own character, which, as is so often the case with modern sherry, port or sweet wine storage, is strongly barrel-driven. Quite exciting here, because Pineau is largely unknown in Germany and the aroma profile in the whisky is 'special' as a result. More notes and reviews on Facebook at: #Maltkanzlei
It took a little while in the glass and a while for me to appreciate this malt. But this is very good and very unique. Delicate and balanced. I have not had good luck with wine barrel finished malts like this one. This is an exception. Quite good
нос · вкус · финиш
| Нос | 83 | Very, very light nose. Spring water, pear and faint cognac |
| Вкус | 88 | Crisp, light, balanced. Pear, white grape. Alcohol is smooth and balanced with some melon and gooseberry. No burn, no hot spice. Travels over the pallet quickly and evenly. Beautiful structure. Lots of body. UNIQUE. Different flavor profile. |
| Финиш | 86 | Medium length but brilliant transition. Seamless. Smooth and clean with cognac notes. |
нос 83 · вкус 85 · финиш 84
Quite sharp for 46%. The alcohol dominates for me. Indicated fruitiness, with a maritime influence. 61-70 - Okay, but not more than 1 dram
нос 68 · вкус 68 · финиш 63
Color gold - a single malt with a very powerful character, - lots of spice, tobacco and oak - a quite complex original bottling - good, but not a candidate from the 3-4 in the evening Glasses are enjoyed, more of an intense pleasure whisky - for 80 - 90€ you can't complain, you don't have to have, but if you are welcome to have access, you have one special direction in the office / bar
...an absolutely interesting malt that is a rollercoaster of flavors - especially in terms of taste! [Color gold;
нос · вкус · финиш
| Нос | 83 | Apricots, peaches, malt, sweetness, honey wine, spices; |
| Вкус | 85 | sweet, silky-oily attack, honey, wine aromas, spices, toffee, caramel, increasing spiciness, pepper, chili, tobacco, oak; |
| Финиш | 84 | good medium-long, peppery-spicy finish; caramel aromas in the aftertaste; |