Отзывы Whiskybase
учтено 19 заметок · текстовых 17 · полный lossless-снимок WB (полнота подтверждена)
The nose is excellent and the best part for me. I had a chance to buy one of these for around £500 roughly 3 years ago ( maybe longer), I wish I had a time machine, to this day Its one of my biggest whisky regrets for a non purchase. BUT being completely honest it is nothing special and there are plenty sherried IB whisky that is better than this, why it is deemed so worthy of value is beyond me because the quality of the liquid does not get near the absurd prices people pay for it.
нос 94 · вкус 89 · финиш 92
I did a tour and tasting at the Macallan distillery in about 2002. Back then you got to do though all the range. Starting with 10yo then the cask strength, 12, 18, 25 and then this 30yo. There was an American on the tour with us and he was driving so he didn't drink any of his so he offered them to me. I couldn't let them go to waste ;) Its quite a long walk back to Cragellachie when your a little drunk ;)
This has to be the finest whisky I have ever tasted, If you like sherried whisky this is as good as it gets.
Its easy to wax lyrical when this is such a famed bottle and it is very good but it is not exceptional which is what you would believe reading all the plaudits it has had. Initially I thought this was a little bitter but the sweetness did develop after time. Its very good, maybe I was expecting a little too much. The nose is lovely, one of the best but the palate lagged behind for me.
Tasted at Old and Rare 2020. Expected sherried profile, pretty much faultless, excellent dram.
A really good Macallan. The price has of course become abstruse. Everyone who has the chance to try this should do so too. The harmony of the sherry and the interplay of the flavors are fantastic.
нос · вкус · финиш
| Нос | 95 | Really old dark sherry, plum, dusty, even slightly floral in the background, orange peel, smells thick |
| Вкус | 94 | Thick, rich and yet clear Sherry / Macallan profile, plum, wood |
| Финиш | 95 | Endlessly long, plum, slightly cherry-like, really watery in the mouth, sherry, woody, old, orange |
нос 93 · вкус 95 · финиш 90
Sold at a auction on ebay for 3460€ January 29, 2020 333497409652
Surprisingly not thin the 43% ABV, it's powerful. Sherry and oak are wonderful. Fruitness is rich. Spices are intense. All together is amazing composition.
Overrated old Macallan. Nice and old with Macallan notes but nothing more.
A medium to full body.
Had the chance to ty this yesterday. Nice wood on the nose, sweet sherry goodness. A little coffey, chocolates, old style sherry whisky. On the palate I found it a bit thin. Not that full mouth coating oilyness that I love. Taste was great tho on the same theme as on the nose. A little bitterness from the oak but nothing bothering. I had a 2cl sample and no drams prior to this one so mouth and nose was fresh. I totally agree with Gregg or Linconimp on this one. The hype and price over this one is just dumb. It’s not worth it by any means. Not even that great a whisky. Just shows how stupid the industry has become. It’s not about great taste anymore but tends to be about hype, brand, value and what not. Sad is what it is..
This was on my Wishlist and happy to say I got my Wish!!! Read the below comment.
нос 93 · вкус 94 · финиш 91
Nose- soysauce, licorice, apple, plum, honey, sherry's unique medicinal scent, faint night flower. Without thinking, the scent is honest and clear. The fragrance is good and good, and the alcohol smell is not felt anywhere, which is great. It reminds me of Celtic Longmorn. Palette- plum, apple, bright stone fruit, raisins, sweet dried fruit. A little bland, but considering the 43 proof, it's strong. Finish- manuka honey, caramel, brown sugar, soy sauce Long and very pleasing. It's one of the best finishes of sherry whisky I've ever had.
So awesome!!! It pays to check out every liquor store you can. This nice gem was found for a low cost of 699$ US it is pretty unbelievable when I saw it myself. Keep searching Men there bound to be more out there. I know I will keep looking. Enjoy the search and have a great year!
best Macallan 30
нос 92 · вкус 93 · финиш 92
Hand signed by Whisky Maker Bob Dalgarno!
@ lincolnimp: Thank you very much, i do absolutely agree ! This bottling has to be left to the collectors. In terms of quality there are much more complex and stunning sherry monsters out there. Not only concerning the relationship between cost and performance (price over 5000 Euros!) this one is really disappointing... (lacks complexity and body!)